Dogs go nuts for this treat, but can cats eat peanut butter? Like some human foods, peanut butter can be eaten safely in moderation, but the answer to the question, "Can cats have peanut butter?" is a little more complicated than "yes" or "no."

Can Cats Eat Peanut Butter?

Although many cats love the taste of this salty and sweet spread, cat parents should avoid giving their feline friends peanut butter. It provides no nutritional value and, more importantly, certain ingredients, like fat and added artificial sweeteners, can be harmful or even toxic to cats.

Problematic Ingredients

If you choose to feed your cat peanut butter, carefully read labels and familiarize yourself with problematic ingredients.

  • Xylitol: When natural peanuts are processed into peanut butter, there are added ingredients that can be hazardous to your cat's health. One such ingredient is xylitol, an artificial sweetener that's toxic to animals. You shouldn't feed your cat products that contain xylitol. Signs of xylitol poisoning include vomiting, drooling, lethargy, balance issues and even seizures, says CatHealth.com. Xylitol pops up in other human foods, like baked goods and chewing gum, which is why reading labels is extremely important.
  • Oil and Fat: Peanuts, despite their name, aren't nuts at all; they're legumes, which are edible seeds grown in pods, like green peas (their above-ground cousin), lentils and other beans. Nutritionally, however, peanuts are considered a nut and contain high amounts of oil and fat. According to The American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (ASPCA), nuts are near the top of the list of people foods to avoid feeding your pet. Although they can be beneficial for humans, these ingredients aren't pet-friendly and can lead to gastrointestinal issues.
  • Sodium: Natural peanuts don't contain any sodium, but roasted peanuts, found in many peanut butters, are high in sodium (and oil). Avoid feeding your cat salty foods, explains the ASPCA, because when ingested in large amounts, your cat could experience vomiting, diarrhea, excessive thirst and/or urination and even depression, seizures and other serious health problems. Much like cats eating cheese, the sodium in human foods can also contribute to heart issues.

Knife with creamy peanut butter

When Can Cats Eat Peanut Butter?

Ideally, you should avoid feeding your cat peanut butter and foods containing it because it poses more health risks than health benefits. Peanut butter tends to be a fan favorite for dog parents for hiding medication or providing a fun snack, but it shouldn't be considered a go-to treat for your cat.

If peanut butter is the only way your cat will ingest their medicine, serve them a very small portion of all-natural peanut butter that doesn't contain xylitol. Portion size matters: A small portion of human food can equal an entire meal for a cat. A tablespoon of peanut butter, for example, would exceed your cat's daily caloric intake, so "stick to a lick" when feeding it to your cat.

Healthy Cat Snacking

Can cats have peanut butter? Yes, but, instead, it's a good idea to give your furry friend alternative treats like cat food with ingredients that provide balanced nutrition. You can hide pills, tablets or even liquid medicine in a ball of wet cat food, and it won't stick to the roof of your cat's mouth like peanut butter.

Sticking to food formulated specifically for your cat can ensure that they meet their proper caloric intake and stay happy and healthy for a long time.

Christine O'Brien Christine O'Brien

Christine O'Brien is a writer, mom, and long-time cat parent whose two Russian Blues rule the house. Her work also appears in Care.com, What to Expect, and Fit Pregnancy, where she writes about pets, pregnancy, and family life. Find and follow her on Instagram and Twitter @brovelliobrien.

Related articles

Choosing the Right Food for Your Senior Cat

Senior cats over age 7 have different nutritional needs than younger cats. Learn what to look for when choosing a food for older and aging felines.

Why Is My Cat Shaking and Shivering?

Why Is My Cat Shaking and Shivering?

Ear Mites in Cats & Kittens: Signs, Symptoms & Treatments

Know the warning signs that your cat might have ear mites, so you can take the proper steps to treat the infectious parasite.

All About Cat Fleas

Discover how your indoor cat can get fleas, how to spot signs that she has them, and tips for getting rid of them & preventing them in the future.

Why Do Cats Bite While Playing?

Learn what's behind your cat's playful biting, whether it's a cause for concern, and how to curtail it if they get a little too rough.

Preparing Your Cat for a New Baby

Learn how your cat's behavior might change if you bring a newborn baby into the home and how you can keep both baby and cat safe.

Feline Infectious Peritonitis: Risk Factors, Symptoms & Treatment of FIP in Cats

Learn helpful info about Feline Infectious Peritonitis, or FIP in cats, including risk factors, common symptoms, treatment options & how to prevent it.

Male Cat Urinary Blockages: Causes, Symptoms & Treatment

While male cat urinary blockages are common, they can be life-threatening. Learn how to spot symptoms and info on prevention, treatments & stress factors.

Liver Disease in Cats: Background, Symptoms & Treatment

Learn about feline liver disease, one of the most common problems affecting a cat's internal organs, including symptoms & treatments for this condition.

Why is My Cat's Meow Silent?

If you're wondering, "Why does my cat meow without sound?" read on to discover what a silent meow actually means (as well as the other types of meows).

How Much Living Space Do I Need for a Cat?

Feeling like you don't have enough space for a cat? Learn the ideal amount of room that cats need to be happy, including space tips for things like eating.

Cataracts in Cats: What You Need to Know

Learn helpful info about cataracts in cats, including what causes them, typical signs of a feline cataract, how they are diagnosed and treatment options.

Cat Zoomies: Why Your Cat Gets Them & When to Call the Vet

Learn why your kitty gets cat zoomies, random bouts of energy that cause them to race through the house, and when zoomies could indicate a health issue.

What Is a Cat's Primordial Pouch?

What is a cat's primordial pouch? You may be surprised to know that it's a natural part of your kitty's biological makeup! Read on to learn more.

What's Behind My Cat's Weird Behaviors?

Learn about the most unique & mystifying cat traits, as well as their meanings. From kneading to hiding, they make us appreciate being cat parents.

Cats Think They're in Charge, Not You

Cats believe that they are in charge of you, not the other way around, and here are three behaviors that might just prove that it's true.

Signs of Stress in Cats and How You Can Help | Hill's Pet

Learn how to recognize the signs of stress in cats and how to help a stressed cat find relief. Learn the implications of stress on her overall health, and what you can do to help ease her.

Fun DIY Beds for Your Cat

Learn how to create four different DIY cat beds that will provide your furry friend with a cozy space of her own & won't break your bank!

Why Do Cats Lick Their Paws? Can it Become Excessive?

Learn common reasons why cats lick their paws, as well as signs when it might be excessive (such as hair loss) & what to do if it seems like a problem.

Is Milk Actually Good for a Cat?

It is a common misconception that cats should be given milk regularly as a treat.