Bringing home a dog from a shelter is always an exciting day. After all, you want that dog to be your close companion for many years to come. But sadly, for some adopted shelter dogs and owners, the relationship doesn't last.
A 2013 study by the American Humane Association found that one in ten pets adopted from a shelter were no longer in the home six months later. The study said the issues surrounding returning a rescue dog are complicated and that "given the complexity of the situation and relationships, it may be unlikely that there is one 'silver bullet' intervention that is likely to markedly increase retention."
The report did find that potential pet parents who were rigid in their expectations of their new pup were more likely to be responsible for returning a rescue dog. Common issues associated with return included those related to time commitment, health and behavioral issues. More specifically:
The AHA study found, perhaps surprisingly, that there was no difference in return rates among owners who had done a lot of research on a pet before adopting and those who made a spur-of-the-moment decision. But the study did find that people who asked for help before returning the pet were more likely to keep the pet than those who had not sought advice from a vet, friends, family or the shelter.
So how can you make sure you don't have to go through the painful process of returning a dog to the shelter? Make sure you research more than what breed of dog you want. Think about how you will react to problematic situations that may arise and how you picture him fitting in with your existing family. Some things to consider:
By doing your homework and understanding that there might be potential issues and behavioral problems as your new dog settles into your home, you can reduce the likelihood that you will make the heartbreaking decision to return your pet to a shelter. Remember that you aren't the only one that is heartbroken when you have to return your pup to the shelter. It is just as hard, or even harder on the dog. Careful consideration ahead of time can ensure that the two of you live happily together for many years to come.
Kara Murphy is a freelance writer and pet parent who lives in Erie, Pa. She has a goldendoodle named Maddie.
For the faster metabolism of Small & Mini dogs
Supports healthy immune system, digestion, lean muscle & beautiful coat
Turkey & Barley recipe with precisely balanced nutrition to keep adult dogs active and healthy
Hill's Science Diet Sensitive Stomach & Skin Small & Mini dry dog food is tailored nutrition for Small & Mini dogs while being gentle on stomachs. Nourishes skin & promotes a lustrous coat.
This weight management and mobility support dog food was created with Hill’s unique understanding of the biology of overweight dogs.
A delicious complement to the nutrition of Science Diet Small & Mini dog food
Science Diet's breakthrough nutrition supports ultimate digestive well-being & healthy microbiome
Over 70% of dogs lost weight within 10 weeks when fed this nutrition
Supports energy & beautiful coat. Helps keep immune system, joints, heart & kidneys healthy
Supports energy level and beautiful coat in mature dogs
Supports energy level & beautiful coat. Helps keep immune system, heart & kidneys healthy
Beef & Barley recipe with precisely balanced nutrition to keep adult dogs active and healthy.
Hill's Science Diet Adult Variety Pack
Hill's Science Diet Sensitive Stomach & Skin dry dog food is gentle on stomachs while nourishing skin & promoting a lustrous coat.
Science Diet's breakthrough nutrition supports ultimate digestive well-being & healthy microbiome
For the faster metabolism of Small & Mini dogs
Science Diet's breakthrough nutrition supports ultimate digestive well-being & healthy microbiome for dogs age 7+
Science Diet's breakthrough nutrition supports ultimate digestive well-being & healthy microbiome. Delicious food in a large bite size
Fewer calories for less active dogs, who prefer smaller kibble
Learn whether soy is a safe ingredient in dog foods, if there are any health benefits or concerns, as well as if they can have products like soy sauce.
Apartment living with a herding dog can be a challenge. Discover these indoor activities for herding dog breeds that can make sharing a small space easier.
Learn about the potential health risks of a raw diet for dogs and why they aren't the best option for your pup or you.
Learn why many dogs are fascinated with chasing cars, why this behavior can be very dangerous, and training tips to help your dog to avoid this behavior.
Learn how to simply and inexpensively build a DIY dog ramp to help your dog get up & down more easily (great for senior dogs & those with mobility issues).
Understand what causes ear infections in your dog and what you can do to help prevent and treat them in the future.
A dog's nose can be an indicator of health, so learn how to best care for your dog if their nose is dry, cracked, warm, red, flaky, or has nasal discharge.
Learn whether cheese is a snack that's safe for your dog, including specific types of cheese, ingredients to watch for and how much is ideal.
Discover what to do if your dog ate soap, including the warning signs to look out for and when to bring them to the veterinarian.
Learn the importance of feeding your puppy or adult dog the right amount of food at proper intervals and find out what feeding method is best for your dog.
Watch out for these 6 common health issues that puppies may develop in their first year of life. Learn all the symptoms so you can provide the best care.
You probably know about female dogs going into heat, but do male dogs? Learn whether male dogs have a heat cycle & handling them around females in heat.
You feed tasty and nutritious dog food, yet your dog only sniffs and licks at it. It’s time for the next meal, but the previous meal still isn’t finished. You might have a finicky dog!
Get helpful tips on how to keep your puppy healthy, including oral and ear care, puppy stress prevention, and more.
Get information on Hill's Pet line of high quality dog treats designed to spoil your perfect dog without spoiling their appetite.
Can Dogs Eat Pumpkin?
Learn important information on blastomycosis in dogs, including how its transmitted, common symptoms, treatment options & geographic considerations.
Learn tips to think about if you're considering a dog for apartment living, including ideal breeds/characteristics & how to make your space dog-friendly.
Learn five essential tips to help you care for your newborn puppies, including how to keep them warm, nursing advice and more.
Discover what types of memories dogs actually have, how their memories work & how long they last, and whether they remember details about their owners.
Our low calorie formula helps you control your dog's weight. It's packed with high-quality protein for building lean muscles, and made with purposeful ingredients for a flavorful, nutritious meal. Clinically proven antioxidants, Vitamin C+E, help promote a healthy immune system.
Our low calorie formula helps you control your dog's weight. It's packed with high-quality protein for building lean muscles, and made with purposeful ingredients for a flavorful, nutritious meal. Clinically proven antioxidants, Vitamin C+E, help promote a healthy immune system.
©2025 Hill's Pet Nutrition, Inc. As used herein, denotes registered trademark status in the U.S. only; registration status in other geographies may be different. Your use of this site is subject to the terms of our Legal Statement. About our Ads. Cookie Consent Tool