Plastic or Soft Dog Cone? Choosing the Best Elizabethan Collar

Cone of Shame. Party Hat. Both of these terms all describe the plastic dog cone or soft dog cone that your pup has to wear after a surgery or injury.

The most common nickname for a dog cone is the Elizabethan collar or E-collar, named after the "ruff," a popular collar style in Britain in the late sixteenth-century during the reign of Queen Elizabeth I. When it comes to dogs, however, this collar is more about function than fashion.

They may look silly, but these collars are not meant to embarrass your pet — they're an important part of your dog's healing process.

Choosing a Dog Cone: What are the Options?

Whether you choose a plastic dog cone or a soft dog cone, opt for one that your dog will tolerate well and that you can work with easily. Dog cones are not a one-size-fits-all product, so work with your veterinarian to find the one best suited for your dog's size and type as well as the location of the affected area.

Plastic Dog Cone

Cones made with lightweight, flexible clear plastic are a go-to for many vets. Many prefer them because they're sturdy and keep your dog in check. "My conclusion is that the plastic cone is the only fool-proof way to avoid incision problems," writes Dr. Phil Zeltzman for Trupanion. Most designs come with fabric-lined edges and Velcro closures for ease of use.

And they're easy to clean: You just wipe off both sides with a damp cloth. You also can add pizzazz to a clear cone by decorating the outside (never the inside) with stickers or decals!

Soft Dog Cone

For dogs who don't tolerate plastic cones well, you can try a foam-padded nylon cone. They come in a variety of styles and colors, most of which use Velcro closures. Many dogs (and dog parents) find soft cones more comfortable because of their flexibility. However, your dog may find ways to nudge the fabric cones aside and access the off-limits area. This can become particularly problematic if you are trying to protect delicate surgery around the eyes or face, as fabric cones cannot and should not be used for surgery of the eyes. Like plastic cones, you can wipe clean a soft cone with some water and gentle soap or even toss it in the washing machine, so long as you always follow product instructions.

Another option is an inflatable cone or an inner tube around your dog's neck. You may even see a dog wearing a cotton T-shirt over their stitches. Speak with your vet before using these or other alternatives to traditional cone, advises Jessica Hamilton, DMV, for MSPCA-Angell, to ensure it's a safe option for your pup.

Why Does My Dog Need a Cone?

Seeing your dog wear a lampshade on their head can be stressful but take heart knowing that vets recommend cones to keep your furry friend safe. Cones prevent pups from scratching or biting an incision or wound, and keep them from licking topical ointments or allergy treatments. Without a cone, your dog may also tear apart surgical staples in just a few minutes, says North Town Veterinary Hospital, which can turn into an expensive and potentially life threatening issue depending on the location of the stitches.